Boston Race Relations During the Antebellum Period

Created by: Daniel Webb
Time Period: 19th Century
Topic: Culture

 

Boston is known by many people as the city where the abolitionist movement in the United States was initiated, however the movement was truly started by the Quakers in Pennsylvania in 1775 with the creation of the first anti-slavery society.[1] Boston however was where the abolitionist movement was born in relation to the antebellum period, and was the city where the most pressure was coming from for the abolishment of slavery in the South. Not only was Boston pressuring the South they were also making progress in the North by being the leading city in legal rights for the African American community living in Boston. It would appear to everyone that Boston would be the destination for African Americans across the country, however the ideal of equality was not quite reached yet in Boston and there was still a strong racist society that imposed social control upon the African Americans and even resisted the legal progress that was being imposed by abolitionist. Boston was a progressive city in the Antebellum period show through the extension of  many legal rights to African Americans as well as the abolitionist movement that was started in the city, however the African American community was still seen as inferior to whites and this can be seen through the legal rights passed to the African Americans, and the beliefs of many abolitionist

At first glimpse one might be persuaded that Boston was a city beyond it’s time in the Antebellum period in the United States. Not only is it given credit (even though as previously stated the Quakers started it) for the abolitionist movement it is seen as, “a leader in legal equality, repealing racial laws and avoiding the restrictions common elsewhere.”[2] This statement has a lot of merit, in 1780 the state of Massachusetts outlawed slavery, also African Americans established the right to vote in 1790, and around 1855 the state had passed legislature for desegregation. Unfortunately though the idea that African Americans would have an impact on the election day in Boston was just an idea. The total African American population in Boston in 1830 was 1,875 people and in 1860 increased a measly 386 people to equal 2,261 people, and the the African American population in Boston accounted for 3.1 percent of the total population in 1830 and drops to 1.3 in 1860.[3] The population of African Americans is just so small within Boston that they really would not have much of an impact on any major decisions that would be voted on. Therefore Boston can allow African American’s to vote and appear to the rest of the United States to be progressive when in fact unfortunately their vote counts for almost nothing.

The next feature of Boston that supports that Boston is still a highly racist city is the ideas about African Americans that are believed by many abolitionists during this time period. The first belief to point out is the white abolitionists’ fight against slavery instead of for equality. This pitted many African Americans against the abolitionists, because while they were against slavery they wanted to be treated equally and not seen as inferior’s within Boston as well and this was just not the mission of the majority of white abolitionist in Boston during the Antebellum period.[4] There were several reasons for these abolitionist to want to fight slavery even if they were not concerned with equality one being to protect the institution of free labor. One of the main points of the free soil party during this time was that slavery was bad for capitalism and that slavery needed to not be expanded into new states, because slavery takes jobs away from people.[5]

Another Important factor though was that many of the Whites in Boston believed that the African American’s were inferior and needed to be guided into civilization. A prime example of this can be seen from abolitionist like James Freeman Clark, who believes African Americans, “the guidance of kind white men was also essential to proper black development.”[6] Many abolitionist were against the idea of a man owning another man, however that African Americans still needed the guidance of the White man. This belief would lead to whites not giving Bostonian African Americans the equality they desired.

Footnotes:

[1] John Daniels, In Freedom’s Birthplace, A Study of the Boston Negroes (Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1914), 30.

[2]Elizabeth Pleck, Black Migration and Poverty: Boston 1865-1900 (New York: Academic Press, 1979), 19.

[3] James Horton and Lois Horton, Black Bostonians: Family Life and Community Struggle in the Antebellum North, (New York: Holmes & Meier Publishers, INC., 1979), 2.

[4] Horton, 93-94.

[5] Horton, 95.

[6] Horton, 94.

Posted in .